How Potion Crafting Games Mirror Natural Skincare Recipes
A reader once sent me a photo of a homemade face mask: lemon juice, baking soda, cinnamon and a few drops of an essential oil she could not remember the name of.

A reader once sent me a photo of a homemade face mask: lemon juice, baking soda, cinnamon and a few drops of an essential oil she could not remember the name of. She had found the recipe in a short video, mixed it in a teacup, and wanted to know why her cheeks were red and stinging two days later. I recognised the logic instantly, because it is the logic of every potion crafting game I have played. Combine ingredients with good reputations, and surely the result is good too.
Potion games are a joy, and I play more of them than I probably should. They also happen to mirror the way a lot of people approach natural skincare, for better and worse. Looking at where the comparison holds and where it breaks is a useful way to think about DIY recipes, especially if your skin is as reactive as mine.
How the games treat ingredients
Potion Craft: Alchemist Simulator (niceplay games, full release 2022) turns brewing into navigation. Each ingredient moves your potion across a map in a particular direction, and grinding it longer with the mortar and pestle changes how far it goes. Adding water pulls the mixture back towards the centre. The genius of the game is that quantity and preparation matter as much as the ingredient itself. Too much of a good thing overshoots the effect you wanted.
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim takes the experimental route. Every ingredient carries four hidden effects, and you discover the first by eating it. Combine two ingredients that share an effect and you get a potion. Many players learn alchemy by tasting everything in sight, which works perfectly in a game where nothing has lasting consequences.
The Witcher 3 adds the idea I wish every DIY recipe came with: toxicity. Each potion Geralt drinks raises a toxicity meter, and if it climbs too high he starts taking damage. Strong preparations have a cost, and the cost adds up when you stack them.
Potionomics (Voracious Games, 2022) is about selling potions, and it is quietly honest about something else: the ingredient with the fanciest name is not always the one doing the work, and price says little about effect.
Where the comparison holds
Potion Craft is right that dose and preparation matter. A drop of tea tree oil diluted in a carrier oil is very different from the same oil applied neat. Most guidance I trust suggests keeping essential oils around one percent for facial use, which works out to roughly one drop per five millilitres of carrier oil. Many homemade recipes online use several times that.
The Witcher is right that strength stacks. An acid toner, a vitamin C serum, a retinol and a homemade scrub can each be fine alone and miserable together. My own skin flared for a week after I layered a fruit enzyme mask on the same night as a retinoid, which is the closest I have come to a real toxicity meter.
Potionomics is right about labels. A cleanser that leads its marketing with a rare botanical extract may contain a fraction of a percent of it, listed near the end of the ingredients. Order on the label roughly follows concentration, so the first five ingredients tell you most of what you are putting on your face.
Where it breaks, and can hurt
Skyrim's taste-everything approach is the dangerous one. Natural ingredients are not gentle by default. Lemon juice on skin followed by sun exposure can cause a burn-like reaction called phytophotodermatitis, and some cold-pressed citrus oils such as bergamot carry the same risk. Baking soda has a pH around 9, while healthy skin sits closer to 5, so a baking soda scrub can leave the protective barrier dry and irritated. Cinnamon is a well known skin sensitiser. The reader's mask had three of these in one teacup.
Games also skip spoilage. A potion in an inventory stays fresh forever. A homemade cream with water in it is an excellent home for bacteria and mould, and without a proper preservative it can go off within days even in the fridge. Oil-only balms and salves keep much better, which is why I steer friends towards those if they want to make something.
A counter-take on "if you can't eat it, don't put it on your skin"
This saying is everywhere in natural beauty circles, and I think it is unhelpful in both directions. Plenty of things you can eat are bad for skin: lemon, cinnamon, garlic, vinegar applied neat. Plenty of things you should never eat are perfectly safe and useful on skin, including zinc oxide in mineral sunscreen and many well tested preservatives. Edibility tells you nothing much. Concentration, pH, sun exposure and how long the product sits on your skin tell you a great deal.
A safer way to experiment
- Start with oil-only recipes such as a simple balm of shea butter and a plant oil. No water means far less risk of spoilage.
- Keep essential oils at about one drop per five millilitres for face products, or leave them out entirely if your skin is reactive.
- Patch test every new mix on the inner forearm for 48 hours before it goes near your face.
- Change one thing at a time. If you add a new toner the same week as a new mask, you will not know which one caused a reaction.
- Skip citrus, baking soda and spices on facial skin, and never apply citrus before going outdoors.
- Make small batches in clean glass, label them with the date, and throw out anything that changes smell or colour.
For ready-made products, the labels and certifications worth trusting are covered in our guide to what eco and ethical labels really mean. Simpler routines and plastic-free swaps live in the natural body care section.
Why I still love these games
None of this makes potion games less fun. If anything, playing Potion Craft after a few years of reading ingredient lists for work made me appreciate how well it captures the feeling of tuning a formula. The difference is that in the game, failure costs a few virtual coins. On a face, it can cost a week of redness. Enjoy the alchemy on screen and keep real experiments slow, small and boring. Other ways games touch on everyday green habits are collected in the games section.
FAQ
Is lemon juice safe as a natural skin brightener?
Not really. It is acidic and can cause a burn-like reaction when skin is exposed to sunlight afterwards. Gentler, tested products are a better choice.
How long should a patch test last?
About 48 hours on the inner forearm. Redness, itching or bumps in that time mean the mix is not for your face.
Which potion game is the most relaxing?
Potion Craft: Alchemist Simulator. There is no combat, and the brewing map rewards slow, careful adjustments.
More in Games
Games
How Online Game Economies Reward Players Who Buy Less
For about two years I opened one particular game every morning before breakfast, not to play, but to check the shop.
Games
How Eco Strategy Games Model Energy Choices for Players
The first time I built a factory in Factorio that ran entirely on solar panels and batteries, I felt smug for about forty...
Games
Find a Cozy Online Game That Celebrates Natural Living
The word "cozy" has been stretched so far in game marketing that it now covers almost anything with soft colours and a cat.